No Religious Affiliation

A recent study from the Pew Research forum released yesterday notes that 46 million Americans have no religious affiliation. This includes 13 million atheists and agnostics as well as 33 million who simply do not identify with a religion. You can find it here:

http://www.pewforum.org/uploadedFiles/Topics/Religious_Affiliation/Unaffiliated/NonesOnTheRise-full.pdf

The largest portion of this demographic are 18-29 year-olds, 32 percent of whom claim no religious affiliation compared to just nine percent of people over the age of 65 who claim no religious affiliation.

The writing, as they say, is on the wall.

Every generation for the past three has been increasingly separating from religion. The increase of the religiously unaffiliated in the United States in the last five years has been an astounding 25 percent.

This cannot continue forever…sooner or later you reach zero.

In the face of such declines one wonders how the church is responding.  Is the church responding? Should the church respond? I wonder how mosques, synagogues and other such places of worship are responding.

The good news for churches is that “no religious affiliation” does not necessarily mean no faith. Many consider themselves spiritual and believers in God. This is good news for believers because it is a foundation to work with so to speak. However it is very clear that church, as it has been done (our methodology), no longer works to provide people with a satisfactory connection to God…church, as it has been done, is increasingly being considered irrelevant. The church believes it is the face of Christ to the world and as such some would console themselves with verses that point out that the world will persecute them as they have Christ and while this is definitely meant in part to console it was primarily meant as a warning to be prepared.

Apathy is the worst form of persecution. To be ignored as if one does not even exist is the height of torment. The church in the west is moving into this because the world is moving in a new direction. Sadly one of the responses to apathy is extremism…have you noticed a rise in religious extremism in the last little while? This is the two-year-old’s strategy to get noticed by mum and dad – to throw tantrums, to throw toys around and to scream “I AM HERE ATTEND TO ME!!!” This is extreme and works great for babies…however it is absolutely terrible for organizations like religions and leads to intense repression, massive backlash, and a heightened desire by the populace to ignore them even more.

The world is a semi-nomadic tribe that periodically packs up its tents and moves on to new regions. The church on the other hand has laid stone foundations deep into the cultural earth and to pack up and move with the world has proven very difficult. The church is not the pillar of cloud and fire that God has been, the pillars that moved as Israel moved. The church is Mount Sinai and Israel is leaving the mountain but the mountain cannot follow – it can only be remembered and periodically visited.

Religion should ultimately be considered ineffective to save and the western world is largely figuring this out. This is the whole direction of scripture…over and over and over again scripture points out that the ways and means of God in human hands are ineffective and serve only to teach us that we are not God and cannot save ourselves. That was the point of the law.

The church, as an engine of religion, has done a great job in fulfilling this mandate by showing that it cannot transform or save humanity. Unfortunately what it failed to do was include itself in this mix of humanity. The church cannot save itself either nor can the agents of the church. Sadly this is not the message the world has received – many in the world see the church very much as the Pharisees of old were seen – a group of righteous to whom one may belong to win God’s favor but outside of which one was lost.

This was one of the main areas of contention Christ had with the Pharisees…they taught that if one kept the law one could find righteousness in the eyes of God. Church leaders may not believe they are like the Pharisees and they may take great offense to this but the reality is, it does not matter what the church thinks but what message is being seen and heard – whether they teach it or not people increasingly see the church as a hypocritical organization that offers righteousness and salvation as an agent…it calls humanity unrighteous and than calls them in to receive righteousness. As the great Canadian Marshall McLuhan has said – “the medium is the message”.

Romans 3:10 says – “As it is written: “There is no one righteous, not even one;”

The struggle the church faces is two-fold – on the one-hand methodology needs to change to reflect the way culture learns and communicates. This is the easy challenge. The hard part is to reflect the character of Romans 3:10 and publicly admit and live out that even the best and brightest Mother Theresa’s and Ghandi’s of the church are as unrighteous as the foulest child raping murderer. It must do this because it is true and testified to in its own scripture.

People know in their hearts that this is the case but often live lives to avoid this truth or try to deny it however they cannot escape it. It is because this inescable truth is imprinted on their hearts that people sniff out the hypocrisy of a church that teaches the depravity of humanity on the one hand and presents a place where one can learn through obedience to law and scripture to be righteous. This is part of what is happening right now.

The entire church must live out the existential bleakness of Romans 3:10; To truly stand at the bottom of the bottomless well and realize that the only hope is the unreachable light that exists far above them. The church must through, active demonstration of their lives testify to their own unrighteousness and desperate need for the unreachable.

Changing the location of services, changing the order of service and adding components etc. falls into methodology which is needed but without the change in the heart (theology) of the people who call themselves ‘Church’, starting with the leaders,  you have the same carton and only the eggs have been moved around…there is no real difference.

Leave a Reply